Healthy peanut butter cookie dough dip

A healthy peanut butter cookie dough dip you won’t feel bad about eating.
Healthy Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Dip

I’m pretty sure sugar should be classified as a drug. Granted, I’ve never tried any sort of illegal substance, but I’d put good money on the fact that it has you addicted as quickly, if not quicker, as the most hardcore stuff out there.

Prior to Friday, I hadn’t had a real dessert in three weeks and I didn’t really even miss it. Fruit or a tiny sliver of dark chocolate did the trick if a craving hit. Then we went away, a 5 course tasting meal and my birthday happened and within 2 days I had consumed more sugar than I probably had in the entire previous month.

And now I want more. And more. And more.

Healthy Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Dip

For as good as those vegetables tasted when we got home, I got hit with an intense craving for something sweet yesterday afternoon. I tried to shut it up with lunch, but it came back 2 hours later. Then I tried to shut it up with a smoothie and it laughed in my face an hour after that.

So here we are with the solution that actually worked.

Healthy Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Dip

And there’s only half a tablespoon of actual sugar in it.

I’ve done the healthy cookie dough dip before and it was good, but this one is on a whole other level thanks to the peanut butter. Pb does an excellent job of masking the “healthy” in this and makes it much smoother than beans ever could.

It’s sinfully delicious and there’s seriously not one ingredient to feel bad about.

Healthy Peanut Butter Cookie Dough Dip

Consider it sugar’s methadone.

5.0 from 2 reviews
Healthy peanut butter cookie dough dip
Prep time
Total time
A sinfully delicious cookie dough dip that you can eat without the guilt.
Recipe type: snacks
Serves: 4-6
  • 5 oz. tofu, drained & pressed (1/4 of a block)
  • ¼ cup oats
  • 2 tablespoons peanut butter
  • ½ tablespoon turbinado sugar
  • ½ teaspoon vanilla extract
  • ¼ teaspoon salt
  • 1 tablespoon cacao nibs
  1. Combine all ingredients except cacao nibs in a food processor and process until smooth, scraping down the sides once or twice.
  2. Add cacao nibs and process for 10-15 seconds more until incorporated and chopped up just slightly.
  3. Keep refrigerated.
*I used extra firm tofu because that’s what I had on hand and it came out fine/smooth. If you have silken, it would probably be even better.


  1. says

    wo wasn’t expecting the tofu- interesting! I find if I get a good sized meal with lots of protein and fat that I don’t crave sugar, but I do agree that once I start its hard to stop!

  2. says

    WHAT?! TOFU?! holy crap. you could’ve fooled me!!! never in a million years would i have thought this was made with tofu..i was reading this and then got to the recipe to see what was really in it to make it healthy and i was completely blown away. consider yourself awesome!

  3. says

    Oh, I am right there with you re: the sugar. I can’t have even a pinch of it or I go on sugar binges for days. Right now, I am on day three of my endless sugar banishment routine. I feel so much better without it, but it always somehow manages to taunt me and drag me back in to its circle of evil. It’s all or nothing with sugar as far as I’m concerned!

  4. says

    I just started picking up tofu for random reasons to attempt to integrate it more and this (along with the banana bread I posted today-YUM!) seem to be great reasons to keep it on hand! I can’t wait to make this for family, watch them gobble it up and then say “it was made with TOFU!!! HAAAA!!!!” (My family won’t eat anything if they know its healthy so this is a perfect sneak in!)

  5. says

    Sugar is definitely addicting. I was doing really well on the no sugar thing too until I had a little handful of jelly beans. That was all it too for the ugly sugar monster to rear it’s head. This dip looks great. I love using tofu for stuff like this. I even made a chocolate PB pie using tofu and no one knew!

  6. says

    Love the tofu in it. Never would have thought of adding tofu in a cookie dough. I’m happy to know I’m not the only one out there who loves cacao nibs!

  7. says

    I make a PB Cookie Dough dip using ricotta!

    Just a small scoop ricotta, scoop of PB, chocolate almond milk (just add until you get the consistency you like), vanilla extract and cinnamon to taste, and mix in a handful of mini choco chips. Tastes just like cookie dough and has lots of protein :)

  8. says

    Great recipe and I’ve seen all kinds of recipes for cookie dough dips but most use 8 oz of cream cheese as the base (not tofu) and I’ve heard some of them taste more like cream cheese dip than cookie dough, which I love cream cheese and all, but want cookie dough to taste like..cookie dough :)

  9. says

    Awesome photos, Gina! I hope you are loving the new lens! And this sounds awesome…I’ve never made it with tofu, but have with chickpeas. Will be trying this version, especially with the PB!

    • Running to the Kitchen says

      I think you’ll love it with tofu! I loved the chickpeas but you could always taste the beans in the background. You really don’t get that with tofu. :)

  10. says

    Wow, I totally wasn’t expecting tofu. I can see how it would be good though – I made a chocolate tofu pudding once with silken tofu and I couldn’t taste the tofu at all(with other varieties I could though). Love this idea to get some extra protein in :)

  11. Sadie says

    I started back on sweets on Easter and cannot get a grip on my cravings. I am all or nothing girl and it looks like I have to get back on the nothing side of things.

  12. says

    The dip sounds awesome. I would’ve never guessed there’s tofu in it! I’ll swap the peanut butter out for almond maybe since I can’t do peanuts and make it soon. I think I might have a sugar craving coming :D I’m off to the kitchen!

  13. Kathrryn says

    Wow.. This makes my mouth really melt.. Actually, I have never tried this one yet and I am sure my kids would love it too..

  14. says

    “Sugar’s methadone” – I love it! I finally succumbed to trying the unhealthy cookie dough dip last week and I’m HOOKED. I’ll definitely have to try this version before I grow out of my whole wardrobe!

  15. says

    I can’t tell you how much I agree with you about sugar being addictive. I recently took a hiatus from sugar and once my sugar hiatus was over, there was pudding, there were milkshakes, there was baklava…frozen yogurt…sigh…it’s like an all or nothing thing as far as I’m concerned. On a separate note, your dip looks awesome and I like the cocoa nibs addition! Never heard of turbinado sugar, but I trust it’s a step above cane sugar?

  16. Laurie says

    Great idea..only I’d have to substitute the sugar added, with …. raisins? or maybe chopped dates? Dried cranberries?

  17. says

    I made a double batch of this yesterday. As with all awesome recipes, I wanted to take a picture and share it on my blog to help spread the love for the recipe. Well it was so good that I never actually got a picture of it, because I finished the whole thing yesterday! It was delicious!! My new favorite way to use tofu.

  18. says

    I’ve also seen this made with chickpeas… You are SO right about sugar. If I cut if out after a few days I don’t miss it, then when you have a little you want more more more!

  19. Guest says

    The more you have it, the more you crave it. The less you have it, the less you crave it. Isn’t that strange how sugar works like that? It’s been over a year since I’ve had any added sugars, and I don’t miss ’em one bit!

    I’ve never had tofu before, but this is such a nifty way to use it! I’d love to try out this recipe (sans sugar, of course, haha) with some sunbutter or almond butter – to help those suckers last a little longer! If it weren’t for the fact that they cost about $7 a jar, I would totally sit down and finish it off in one day, whoops!

  20. Amity says

    When I saw this recipe, I was intrigued. I tried it and am WOW’d!!!! This recipe was awesome. Thanks!!!!!

  21. says

    Just made this! Tried to be fancy and make it more like plain cookie dough dip by using 1 1/2 tbsp cashew butter and just 1/2 tbsp peanut butter, and I could still taste the tofu – I don’t mind the taste of tofu but probably most would, so I added more peanut butter and it was wunderbar! So yeah, don’t try to be fancypants like me and mess with a great recipe – it’s fabuloso Gina! Ooh yes – and I removed the sugar and instead used vanilla stevia. But again, I don’t mind the flavour of stevia. It was yummy!

  22. Katie says

    Yummm! I made this earlier today and it’s very good. The taste is very similar to cookie dough. I used silken tofu, Better ‘N Peanut Butter, and a few drops of butter extract in addition to everything else. I have to say I really do like the texture that beans give to cookie dough dips, but I was still really happy to find a recipe without beans! They make it too heavy, especially the way I’ll be eating it (spoonful after delicious, healthy spoonful).

    My recipe made about 4 servings, or 8 tablespoons (at about 80 calories per serving) but it won’t be lasting long. :)


  1. […] stop tormenting me in my sleep.-Christina’s cookie dough bites. I know I just made a damn good healthy cookie dough dip but this real version in those perfect little chocolate balls is just killlling me. I […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: